Part 36 offers explained: costs consequences and tactics

HomeUncategorizedPart 36 offers explained: costs consequences and tactics

Quick look

A Part 36 offer is a formal written offer to settle made under Part 36 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It must comply with CPR 36.5 and specify a relevant period of not less than 21 days. Its force lies in the costs consequences that follow if it is not accepted and the offeree does no better at trial, which can include indemnity costs, interest at up to 10% above base rate, and an additional amount capped at £75,000.

Part 36 is the most powerful costs tool in civil litigation, and the one most often deployed without a clear understanding of what it actually does. A well-judged Part 36 offer transfers costs risk to the other side and keeps it there for the life of the claim. A badly drafted one is simply an offer, with none of the consequences the maker assumed they had secured.

The rules themselves are not long. What makes Part 36 difficult is that two separate regimes sit inside it, governed by different rules with different outcomes, and practitioners regularly argue for one while the facts engage the other.

What is a Part 36 offer?

A Part 36 offer is a formal offer to settle the whole of a claim, part of it, or a particular issue within it, made in accordance with the procedure in Part 36. Either party may make one, at any stage, including before proceedings are issued.

It is a self-contained code. Part 36 operates on its own terms rather than as an application of the ordinary law of offer and acceptance, and an offer that does not comply with the formalities is not a Part 36 offer at all, whatever it is headed. It may still be a useful offer, but it will fall to be dealt with under the court's general discretion on costs rather than the mandatory scheme.

The formal requirements

Under CPR 36.5, a Part 36 offer must:

  • be in writing;
  • make clear that it is made pursuant to Part 36;
  • specify a period of not less than 21 days within which the defendant will be liable for the claimant's costs if the offer is accepted, known as the relevant period;
  • state whether it relates to the whole of the claim or to part of it, or to an issue in it, and if so which;
  • state whether it takes into account any counterclaim.

The relevant period is the pivot on which everything else turns. Nearly every costs consequence in Part 36 is expressed by reference to whether something happened before or after it expired, which is why the date of service matters as much as the content of the offer.

Offers are not shown to the trial judge

A Part 36 offer is treated as without prejudice except as to costs. The fact that one has been made is not communicated to the trial judge until the case has been decided, so that the court's determination of the issues is not influenced by knowing what either side was prepared to accept.

That is the same principle that governs without prejudice correspondence, applied through a formal scheme with prescribed consequences rather than through the parties' agreement.

Acceptance and judgment are governed by different rules

This is the distinction that causes the most trouble, and it is worth stating plainly before going any further.

What happens when an offer is accepted is governed by CPR 36.13. What happens when an offer is not accepted and the case goes to judgment is governed by CPR 36.17. They produce very different outcomes, and the enhanced consequences practitioners associate with Part 36 belong only to the second.

The common error. Late acceptance of a claimant's offer does not give the claimant indemnity costs, enhanced interest or the additional amount. Those arise under CPR 36.17 following judgment. Late acceptance is dealt with under CPR 36.13, and the usual order is a split of costs at the expiry of the relevant period.

Acceptance within the relevant period

Where an offer is accepted in time, the claimant is entitled to its costs of the proceedings up to the date on which notice of acceptance was served, assessed on the standard basis if not agreed. The defendant's exposure stops there.

Acceptance after the relevant period

Where acceptance is late, the default position under CPR 36.13 is a split. The defendant pays the claimant's costs up to the end of the relevant period, and the claimant pays the defendant's costs from the end of that period to the date of acceptance. The court may order otherwise, but it will not do so lightly.

The practical effect is a period of costs protection for the offeror that bites the moment the relevant period expires, without any need to get to trial.

Costs consequences following judgment: CPR 36.17

Where the offer is not accepted and the case is decided, the consequences depend on who made the offer and how the judgment compares to it.

Where the claimant fails to beat a defendant's offer

If the claimant obtains a judgment that is not more advantageous than the defendant's Part 36 offer, the court must, unless it considers it unjust, order the claimant to pay the defendant's costs from the end of the relevant period, together with interest on those costs.

This is why a defendant's Part 36 offer is such an effective instrument. A claimant can win the claim outright and still pay the defendant's costs for most of the litigation, because the ordinary rule that costs follow the event is displaced from the date the relevant period expired.

Where the claimant beats its own offer

If the claimant obtains a judgment at least as advantageous as the proposals in its own Part 36 offer, CPR 36.17(4) provides that the court must, unless it considers it unjust, order four things.

RuleConsequence
36.17(4)(a)Interest on the sum awarded, excluding interest, at up to 10% above base rate, from expiry of the relevant period
36.17(4)(b)Costs on the indemnity basis, including recoverable pre-action costs, from expiry of the relevant period
36.17(4)(c)Interest on those costs at up to 10% above base rate
36.17(4)(d)An additional amount, capped at £75,000

The additional amount is calculated as 10% of the first £500,000 awarded, plus 5% of any amount between £500,000 and £1 million. Where the award exceeds £1 million, the additional amount is the £75,000 cap. It applies to offers made on or after 1 April 2013.

Of the four, the one that usually carries the greatest value in practice is the indemnity costs order, because assessment on the indemnity basis removes proportionality from the equation, and proportionality is where bills are most often reduced.

The unjust exception

The consequences are mandatory unless the court considers it unjust to order them. CPR 36.17(5) directs the court to take into account all the circumstances, including the terms of the offer, the stage at which it was made, the information available to the parties at the time, the conduct of the parties in relation to the giving or refusing of information for the purposes of evaluating the offer, and whether the offer was a genuine attempt to settle.

That last factor matters. An offer pitched so close to the maximum recoverable that it concedes nothing may be found not to be a genuine attempt to settle, in which case the machinery does not engage.

Fixed recoverable costs change the arithmetic

Where a claim falls within the fixed recoverable costs regime, the position is different and the difference is easy to miss.

A claimant who beats its own offer in a fixed costs case does not obtain open-ended indemnity costs. Instead the entitlement under CPR 36.24 is an uplift of 35% on the difference between the fixed costs for the stage at which the relevant period expired and those applicable at the date of judgment.

That is a capped benefit rather than an open one, and it changes the tactical calculation in lower-value claims considerably. Claiming CPR 36.17 consequences in a fixed costs case, or CPR 36.24 in a standard basis case, undermines the rest of the argument on assessment.

Withdrawal and change

A Part 36 offer can be withdrawn or its terms changed, and the mechanics depend on timing.

Once an offer has been withdrawn it no longer attracts the Part 36 costs and interest consequences, although a party may still argue that the court should take it into account under its general costs discretion in CPR 44.2. That is a materially weaker position, because the discretion is not the mandatory scheme.

The decision to withdraw therefore gives up something of real value, and is worth taking deliberately rather than as housekeeping when a case moves on.

Liability-only offers after Smithstone

The most significant recent development concerns offers that deal only with liability, and it resolves a question that had been live for several years.

In Smithstone v Tranmoor Primary School [2026] EWCA Civ 13, handed down on 16 January 2026, the claimant had made a Part 36 offer on 13 December 2018 to settle liability on a 90/10 basis. The defendant rejected it. The claim later settled globally for £2,650, approved by the court under CPR 21.10 because the claimant was a child.

The Court of Appeal decided two points of principle in the claimant's favour. A settlement approval under CPR 21.10 is capable of being a judgment for the purposes of CPR 36.17. And a liability-only offer, including a split-liability offer such as 90/10, is in principle capable of engaging the costs consequences in CPR 36.17(4). In reaching that conclusion the court disagreed with the reasoning in Mundy v TUI UK Ltd [2023] EWHC 385 (Ch), holding the relevant observations of Collins-Rice J to have been obiter and wrong. Bean LJ emphasised that liability-only offers should be encouraged, both in multi-track cases with a separate liability trial and in fast-track matters.

The appeal was nonetheless dismissed on its facts. Liability was never admitted by the defendant nor determined by the court, so there was no finding against which the 90/10 proposal could be compared, and the global settlement could not be characterised as at least as advantageous as the offer. The court also declined to depart from the fixed costs regime, holding it would not be unjust to confine the claimant's solicitors to fixed costs.

The practical rule that emerges is narrow and should be stated carefully. Part 36 consequences can follow a liability-only offer, but only where liability has actually been determined or admitted, so that the outcome can be meaningfully compared with the offer. A case that settles globally without any resolution of liability will not engage them.

The decision is also a clean illustration of why the distinction between ratio and obiter is not academic. An approach that had been shaping litigation behaviour since 2023 turned out to rest on observations that were not binding.

Making a Part 36 offer that works

Five practical checks

  1. Comply with CPR 36.5 exactly. Say on the face of the document that it is made under Part 36, specify a relevant period of not less than 21 days, and state whether it covers the whole claim, part of it or an issue, and whether it accounts for any counterclaim.
  2. Diarise the expiry of the relevant period. Every consequence runs from that date, and service determines when it starts.
  3. Pitch it as a genuine attempt to settle. An offer that concedes nothing invites an argument under CPR 36.17(5) that enforcing the consequences would be unjust.
  4. Identify the costs regime before advising. Whether the claim is within fixed recoverable costs determines whether the prize is indemnity costs or a 35% uplift, and the two are not interchangeable.
  5. Make it early. The protection runs from the expiry of the relevant period, so an offer made late protects only a short tail of costs. The value of a Part 36 offer is substantially a function of when it was served.

Where an offer is being used to narrow a case rather than dispose of it, consider an issue-based offer. Smithstone confirms these can engage the scheme, provided the issue is one that will actually be determined or admitted.

How Part 36 relates to other settlement tools

Part 36 does not displace ordinary settlement correspondence. A Calderbank offer, made without prejudice save as to costs outside the Part 36 scheme, remains available and retains a role where Part 36 does not fit the situation. What it does not carry is the mandatory consequences, so the outcome depends on the court's general discretion.

Pre-action conduct also matters. The pre-action protocols expect parties to attempt settlement before issuing, and recoverable pre-action costs are expressly within the indemnity costs order available under CPR 36.17(4)(b). An offer made before proceedings begin is not wasted.

This article is information and analysis, not legal advice. The costs consequences of a Part 36 offer depend on the terms of the offer, the applicable costs regime and the outcome of the case. Confirm the current rules before advising.

Key takeaways

  • A Part 36 offer must comply with CPR 36.5 and specify a relevant period of not less than 21 days, or it is not a Part 36 offer at all.
  • Acceptance is governed by CPR 36.13; judgment by CPR 36.17. The enhanced consequences belong only to the latter.
  • Late acceptance normally produces a split of costs at expiry of the relevant period, not indemnity costs.
  • A claimant who beats its own offer may obtain indemnity costs, interest at up to 10% above base rate on damages and costs, and an additional amount capped at £75,000.
  • The additional amount is 10% of the first £500,000 and 5% of the next £500,000, for offers made on or after 1 April 2013.
  • A claimant who fails to beat a defendant's offer pays the defendant's costs from expiry of the relevant period, even if the claim succeeds.
  • In fixed recoverable costs cases the reward is a 35% uplift under CPR 36.24, not indemnity costs.
  • Smithstone v Tranmoor Primary School [2026] EWCA Civ 13 confirmed liability-only offers can engage CPR 36.17, but only where liability is determined or admitted.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Part 36 offer?

A formal written offer to settle made under Part 36 of the Civil Procedure Rules, carrying prescribed costs consequences if it is not accepted and the offeree does no better at trial.

How long is the relevant period for a Part 36 offer?

Not less than 21 days. The offer must specify it, and almost every costs consequence runs from the date it expires.

What happens if you beat your own Part 36 offer?

Unless it would be unjust, the court orders indemnity costs from expiry of the relevant period, interest on damages and on those costs at up to 10% above base rate, and an additional amount capped at £75,000.

How is the Part 36 additional amount calculated?

10% of the first £500,000 awarded and 5% of any amount between £500,000 and £1 million, subject to the £75,000 cap.

What happens if a Part 36 offer is accepted late?

The usual order under CPR 36.13 is that the defendant pays the claimant's costs to the end of the relevant period, and the claimant pays the defendant's costs from then until acceptance. Late acceptance does not itself trigger indemnity costs.

Can a Part 36 offer be withdrawn?

Yes. Once withdrawn it no longer attracts the Part 36 consequences, though a party may still ask the court to take it into account under its general costs discretion in CPR 44.2.

Does Part 36 work differently under fixed recoverable costs?

Yes. A claimant who beats its own offer in a fixed costs case receives a 35% uplift under CPR 36.24 rather than indemnity costs.

Can a Part 36 offer deal only with liability?

Yes. Smithstone v Tranmoor Primary School [2026] EWCA Civ 13 confirmed liability-only offers can engage CPR 36.17, but the consequences follow only where liability is determined or admitted.

Is a Part 36 offer shown to the trial judge?

No. It is treated as without prejudice except as to costs and is not communicated to the trial judge until the case has been decided.

What is the difference between a Part 36 offer and a Calderbank offer?

A Part 36 offer carries mandatory costs consequences if the formalities are met. A Calderbank offer sits outside the scheme and its effect depends on the court's general discretion on costs.